Importance of Accountability in Local Government
What you need to ensure an ethical, accountable local government.
- The importance of ethics in government accountability.
- Ways to create a culture of accountability in local government.
Accountability is an important part of any organization, but it’s especially important in local government.
Governments must responsibly use their resources to provide services that meet the needs of constituents. Local governments answer to state and federal laws and guidelines for effective operations.
But most of all, they answer to the people they serve.
As discussed in an earlier blog post, creating a culture of accountability improves employee morale, increases effectiveness, and protects against liability risks.
Governments have many different departments, and there can be a wide variance in standards between them.
Accountability measures help departments meet goals and work together. Plus, organizations that emphasize accountability can recognize problems and continually improve.
However, accountability in local government is about more than just efficient internal operations. Ultimately, government accountability is about maintaining the trust between government officials and citizens.
The Importance of Ethics in Government Accountability
Local governments not only need to operate lawfully and ethically, but they need to work hard to avoid even the appearance of impropriety.
Accountability should be a concern for all local government employees, not just elected officials.
Governments won’t be able to fulfill their roles if citizens don’t trust all government employees to make decisions that serve the best interest of the community.
Even the appearance of questionable behavior can hurt public trust.
Therefore, accountability in local government requires strict standards and procedures to promote ethical behavior. As a report by City Ethics points out:
“Because we cannot know the character or motivations of those who manage our communities, and because we cannot know how much their personal obligations affect their decisions, we can judge them, and hold them accountable, only by their actions and their relationships as they appear on their face.
“In other words, in government ethics, appearances are what matters most. Motivations, feelings, and character are irrelevant.”
Ways to Create a Culture of Accountability in Local Government
Integrity and accountability must be deeply ingrained in the culture of local government. This starts at the top.
Local governments should focus on ethical values. Government agencies should teach leaders and supervisors to lead with those principles at the center of everything they do.
As Brent Gleeson wrote in an article in Forbes:
“[Values-based leadership] just means leading the team and evaluating performance – both your own and the team's – based more so on the organization's set of values rather than specific metrics and milestones.
Managers still have to oversee their team member's ability to execute and be accountable for their role in mission success, but values-based evaluations can't be an afterthought.”
For local governments, core values such as integrity, equality, and transparency should provide the foundation for every decision and policy.
Citizens won’t care if the government achieves results if government employees do it through misusing funds, cutting corners, or accepting bribes.
People need to be able to trust their local government to act responsibly. This makes transparency and public disclosure especially important.
Citizens should be able to see how the government is spending their tax money, what services the government is providing, and how government officials are working to improve the community.
The International City/County Management Association encourages local governments to focus on the fundamentals to build an ethical foundation.
”If the organization lacks a code of ethics or statement of values, implement a process that engages elected officials, staff, and residents in the definition of core values and acceptable conduct. If you have a code of ethics, is there clarity and agreement on the core values that drive critical decisions? Organizations or teams with shared values produce the best results.
“Use council orientations and goal-setting sessions to encourage elected officials to understand how their conduct and commitment to public service values contribute to ethical government.”
Most employees don’t set out intending to act unethically. Employees may be intent on an end goal – completing a project within budget, hiring someone they trust, meeting a deadline – and just overlook a potential ethical problem in the equation.
As the National Conference of State Legislatures points out, “Many ethics violations occur when people are unaware or ignorant of the law as it pertains to their position.”
Of course, ethics is more complex than just following the rules. Laws can’t cover everything. And some have loopholes.
An action doesn’t have to be illegal to be unethical. Employees need to know that they can follow the technical letter of the law and still be acting unethically. And even perceived ethics violations can violate public trust.
Ethics in government is different and more complex than personal ethics. Often, ethical accountability in local government has to do with the conflicts between the responsibilities of the government and an employee’s personal obligations.
It’s important for government employees to remember that they represent the government, so they need to uphold the integrity of the institution as a whole.
Of course, values-based leadership will help employees keep this in perspective. But ethics training is also an essential part of accountability in local government.
Ethics training should include discussions about values and standards for ethical behavior. The training makes employees aware of common ethical issues. And it gives them tools for making ethical decisions when faced with gray areas where laws may not clearly apply.
Ethics training is especially important for employees in certain areas.
For example, employees working in procurement, finances, permitting, and zoning positions may face ethical issues more than other employees.
However, accountability in local government should include ethics training for all employees and officials. Training should be part of the onboarding process, but governments should also conduct annual retraining.
City Ethics has a list of good resources for ethics training.
Written policies and procedures
Part of accountability in local government is setting expectations in writing, and then consistently applying and enforcing those policies.
We’ve written before about why policies and procedures are important for every organization.
Subscribe to Our Newsletter
Stay on top of the latest trends in local government and policy management.
You will receive our next newsletter in your inbox soon.
Policies and procedures help employees know how to do their jobs properly and effectively. They establish roles, acceptable behavior, and the responsibilities of each department and employee.
Policies and procedures also provide a framework for a culture of accountability and formalize accountability measures. But policies and procedures alone don’t ensure accountability.
Government leaders and administrators must have a way to make sure employees read and understand policies. Policy management software can help with this.
Policies should always start with the underlying principles and values of the organization. For local government agencies especially, it’s important for policies to include a code of conduct and a code of ethics.
The code of ethics may cover things like conflicts of interest, nepotism, and endorsement.
It should lay out the disciplinary actions for employees or officials who violate the code of ethics. It should also establish procedures for reporting unethical behavior and establish measures to protect whistle-blowers.
Of course, this also starts with a culture of accountability in local government.
When the agency’s culture is based on values and accountability, employees will feel safe to report bad behavior. And citizens will know that government officials will be held accountable for unethical actions.
For a good place to start in crafting a code of ethics, see City Ethics’ Model Code of Ethics.
Independent ethics commission or officer
To promote accountability in local government, the people overseeing the ethics program need to be independent of the government itself.
The City Ethics report highlights why this is important:
“Since government ethics is all about conflicts, it is crucial that there not be any conflicts in the ethics program itself. In practice, this means that no official under the jurisdiction of an ethics program should have any special role in the program.
“In addition, the selection of ethics commission members by high-level officials makes it look to the public like they control the program. This undermines trust in the program and means that citizens don’t bother filing complaints.”
The makeup of an ethics program may look different depending on the size and needs of a particular local government.
Small governments may not have the budget to hire an ethics officer. But they could consider teaming up with nearby cities or counties to create an ethics program that covers a broader area.
In any case, the person or group should enforce the code of ethics, propose ethics policies, and give advice on how to proceed with individual situations.
They should initiate investigations into potential violations and make sure the government follows through on proper disciplinary measures if an employee has acted unethically.
The Office of Government Ethics is a good place to find more information and training resources.
Accountability audits and assessments
To achieve a culture of accountability, local governments need to be aware of areas where there is a lack of accountability.
An accountability audit assesses how local governments use public funds and resources.
It evaluates whether the government has proper controls in place to make sure employees aren’t misusing resources. And it ensures that the government is following laws, regulations, and internal policies and procedures.
Some states require accountability audits.
For example, the state of Washington requires audits at least once every three years. But even if a local government isn’t legally obligated, performing regular self-audits or assessments is a good way to identify issues or potential concerns so they can be corrected.
Audits can be done internally or by the independent ethics council or officer.
Accountability in local government is more important now than ever before.
Ultimately, local governments are accountable to citizens, and they must show that they are worthy of trust.
Creating a culture of accountability will help local governments build trust with citizens, operate more effectively, and better serve the public.